Blog

Don’t Let Confirmation Bias Narrow Your Perspective

If we limit our news and opinion information consumption to publications that we agree with, we are looking at the world through myopic lenses and miss many other valid arguments/ideas. As always, look for evidence for any argument/idea and also verify the source as credible. Here is a quick study of confirmation bias that we all have to combat as we react to what we encounter on social media or in the news.

National News Literacy Week

Save the dates! The annual National News Literacy Week (Jan. 23-27) is presented in partnership with The E. W Scripps Company. This year’s NNLW theme is trust: What makes a source of news or information trustworthy or credible? And why is trust important in news consumption? Each day of the week will feature events, resources and engaging discussions. We hope you’ll save the dates — NNLW registrations coming soon!

Don’t wait for information to be debunked. Learn to “prebunk”.

From: Elizabeth Gilbert from Big Think November 8, 2022
Learn to identify common misinformation techniques with these five videos. The techniques include: 1)emotional language to induce fear, anger or contempt 2)Incoherence like using multiple arguments about the same topic which cannot all be true 3) False dichotomies such as falsely presenting sides or choices as mutually exclusive 4) Scapegoating which is singling out groups or individuals for unwarranted blame 5)Ad hominem attacks that target the person rather than their arguments.

One real world example of prebunking happened when world leaders were warned that Russia would likely use false information to justify their invasion of Ukraine in 2022.

Three Types of Election Rumors to Avoid

The following is taken directly from the News Literacy Project:

“Elections are the lifeblood of democracy, but political campaigns are often rancorous, controversial and polarizing events. As if the misleading claims and attack ads weren’t challenging enough for the public, bad actors further muddy the waters by pushing disinformation into our social media feeds.

These harmful falsehoods are designed to cause confusion and to undermine people’s faith in American democracy. Election disinformation can be tricky, but the same false narratives and claims tend to get recycled, which can make it easier to spot.

This infographic outlines three common types of election disinformation that are likely to circulate on social media during election cycles in the United States. It also includes tools and tips for locating credible information in your state or district.

Being familiar with recurring election disinformation themes can help inoculate you against the allure of new incarnations and iterations that occur regularly. It can also help you more efficiently debunk them and warn your friends and family members not to get taken in.

The three types of election disinformation this infographic focuses on are:

  • “Ballot mule” accusations: A substantial portion of election misinformation revolves around baseless claims of voter fraud. Accusations of people (“mules”) illegally gathering large numbers of fraudulent ballots and delivering them to ballot drop boxes have become particularly common, despite the fact that such allegations lack evidence. More often, people who are authorized to return multiple ballots — such as designated agents for nursing home residents — are incorrectly portrayed as engaging in schemes to swing elections. Be wary of photos and videos of people delivering ballots that are framed as “evidence” of this type of fraud, which is extremely rare.
  • Mail-in ballot rumors: Voting by mail is increasingly popular, but people are vulnerable to believing baseless allegations of mishandling ballots, partly because the chain of custody is less direct than with in-person voting. But mail-in voting is no less secure than in-person voting and examples of fraud remain rare (usually involving someone attempting to return a mail-in ballot previously requested by a since-deceased relative or housemate). If you see a claim about fraudulent mail-in voting, be extremely cautious and take time to verify it at least one credible source.
  • Poll worker rumors: The increase in livestreams of election workers doing their jobs has given lots of raw fodder to strong partisans looking for anything they can construe as fraud. Keep in mind that there is legitimate and necessary election work that ordinary people are unfamiliar with and don’t entirely understand. Watch out for video clips and images out of context claiming that poll workers are manipulating the vote.”

Leaving Conspiracy Theories

A single mom in Mississippi embraced multiple conspiracy theories until one day she questioned the validity of an acquaintance’s claim that the Earth is flat. Karen Robertson, 30, shared her journey out of belief in conspiracy theories with a student reporter from PBS Student Reporting Labs. She said a previous abusive relationship led her to these beliefs. “I was trying to make the world make sense, and it was easier to believe that it was a bad place and something was out to get you, and that’s why my life was where it was at and as bad as it was, than it was to realize I had made bad choices.” Robertson encouraged others to question conspiracy theories. “When I challenged my beliefs, it changed my world and it made my life better.” News Lit Quiz: Avoid the trap of conspiratorial thinking.